In the US media, with many of the discussions on the recent healthcare law, Canada keeps getting mentioned as a socialist country. We moved to Canada in February 2007 and I experienced a big shock about how more privatized it was than the US. Below is a repost from a blog entry I made in November 2008 on this topic.
Is Canada socialist other than its universal health care system?
QUESTION left on one of my blog entries:
Quick question regarding your Canadian status:
I'm just curious. Do you think Canada is socialist other than its universal health care system? Or do they call their form of government something else? You know there are a bunch of wackos down here calling Obama a socialist, and personally, even though I don't think he's a socialist, I see nothing wrong with socialism. I can't think of a negative thing to say about it. I've been in a couple of socialist countries and witnessed the citizens' way of life, have asked them about their taxes, etc., and I honestly think they have a better quality of life in those countries than we do here in the States. (I'm talking France and Italy.) I've been to Canada, too, but not for a significant amount of time to really get to know people personally, eat dinner in their homes, go on family trips with them, and witness their day-to-day living habits.
Thanks!

ANSWER @UFFda_oyVEY - Many Canadians would say they have some socialist programs, but have mostly a capitalistic economy. There is a lot of variation from province to province on this. In Alberta, we pay $44/mo per person for our health card and there are residency requirements, whereas you see in the movie Sicko people in Ontario not having any cost. [update: since this post, Alberta no longer requires a monthly payment per person. And I also didn't mention Albertans still pay for dental, prescription drugs and eyecare.]
Think about what things in the US are "socialized" (or some people call it "Federalized.) The post office, the schools, social security, welfare, etc.
For our experience, we have found Alberta to be VASTLY WAY MORE PRIVATIZED than the US. In Alberta there are many instances where the funds still come from the government, but the service has been contracted out to private companies to provide. Many of these work just fine like your post office is in convenience stores, drug stores, etc. You go to various private companies called registries to get your drivers license, business incorporation, license plates, etc. Public & Private schools compete for the same pool of government funds so there are specialty schools for religions, athletics, dance, science and immersion in many different languages.
Segments of regulation are even privatized here. To set up my dayhome, I had to go through a "Family Dayhome Agency" which is a private company that has been contracted by the government to approve me and monitor me monthly. There are 6 different companies that do this in Edmonton. I could offer my service privately, but it would be considered babysitting and one of my moms who is poor and single would not be able to access subsidy for her childcare.
Another example of the government contracting with a private company that affects us directly here Edmonton is the whole recruitment and signup process for fosterparenting and adoption of foster children. I'm not sure that making money off of providing social services to children is ever a good idea.
And then there is pure de-regulation. The Gas company we randomly picked when we moved here has terrible marketing practices. They run two businesses with the same logo & similar names & through their website we accidently signed up for their unregulated bad 5 year contract. We come from Idaho where a 5 year contract for your utility is unimaginable. And this company has marketers that knock on your door at 9pm at night trying to get you to sign up for additional services.
The 2008 Canadian listeriosis outbreak can heavily be blamed on the Conservative Harper government's policy that food companies should regulate themselves. And you can see that Maple Leaf did a very poor job of self-regulation!
As I've said many times, Canada is no Utopia. There are still major issues up here. We moved here in 2007 for many reasons like the political differences, the cultural focus on family and to avoid the pending US Economic explosion. I want to say, if anyone is looking to move, its a great place to live. Here in Edmonton, the unemployment recently fell to 3.4% while in the US, joblessness has hit 10 million people. The US unemployment rate is now at Clinton era levels - 6.1% and is expected to continue growing to 8 - 8.5% next year. This article even mentions 10 - 11% unemployment if an auto company fails. If you are looking for work and think Canada might be for you, here is the place to find out if you are eligible for Canadian Immigration.
Recent Comments